Toast & Tonic: Bakery Restaurant in Mystic
At the heart of Olde Mistick Village, Toast & Tonic has quickly become a vibrant favorite among Mystic’s culinary crowd. Established in 2023 by Chef Aimee Filippetti—a Mystic native and Culinary Institute of America graduate—the restaurant and bakery effortlessly blends creative California-style breakfast, brunch, and lunch with New England hospitality and chic, welcoming vibes.
Fresh, Inventive Menus All Day
Toast & Tonic celebrates early birds and leisurely lunch-goers alike with a daytime menu full of inventive plates. Signature dishes span decadent classics like crab omelets with hollandaise and lobster Benedict, alongside modern takes such as sweet potato toasts with goat cheese, bacon, and candied pecans. The bleu cheese grilled sandwich with caramelized onions, bacon, and tomato is a savory must, and bowls like shakshuka and the Olde Mistick skillet offer vegetarian and hearty options. For something sweet, don’t miss the ricotta pancakes or pumpkin pie crepes.
Chef Aimee’s attention to ingredient quality and unique pairings shines throughout the menu, helped by partnerships with local bakeries—think Alberto’s Bakery rye and Nana’s naturally leavened country loaves. Gluten-free bread is readily available, and there’s a clear focus on offering dietary flexibility.
Sweet Treats from Never Enough Bake Shop
Every dessert and pastry at Toast & Tonic comes from Never Enough Bake Shop, the acclaimed sister bakery located within the same building. Chef Aimee’s background in pastry arts is evident in the array of in-house baked goods, from custom cakes to artisanal sweets. These aren’t just desserts—they’re part of the experience, making it hard to leave without picking up a treat for later.
Craft Cocktails & Community Vibes
Toast & Tonic isn’t just about food—it’s also a lively spot for friends to unwind with carefully crafted cocktails, local beer, or a glass of wine. Their signature drinks are highlighted during the all-day Friday happy hour and again on Saturday afternoons, making it a great spot for an early evening toast or a weekend catch-up with friends.
Toast & Tonic Atmosphere & Experience
Visitors are greeted by a bright, stylish interior decorated with local charm and a friendly staff. Outdoor seating on the porch is available in warmer months, perfect for soaking up the lively energy of Olde Mistick Village. Chef Aimee’s hands-on approach is felt everywhere, from personal touches in the décor to the rotating menu of deviled egg specials and salads.
The Verdict
For Mystic locals and visitors, Toast & Tonic delivers a chef-driven, modern twist on New England daytime dining. With its inventive menu, spectacular pastries, and community spirit, it’s a must-visit in Olde Mistick Village for memorable breakfasts, brunches, and lunches—plus a little something sweet to take home.
Note: Custom cakes and desserts from Never Enough Bake Shop can also be ordered online, making Toast & Tonic a destination for celebrations large and small.
