Things to do in Greater Mystic!
When it comes to pizza, Mystic, CT, offers a slice of something for every craving—whether you’re searching for wood-fired artisanal pies, classic New England comfort, or a taste of history in a coastal setting. With its blend of traditional favorites and creative new offerings, Mystic’s pizza scene is a highlight for visitors and locals alike.
No discussion of pizza in Mystic is complete without mentioning the legendary Mystic Pizza. Made famous by the 1988 film of the same name, this downtown institution has been serving up “A Slice of Heaven” since 1973. The menu features a range of classic pizzas—cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, and veggie—alongside calzones, salads, and hearty Italian-American fare. Its old-school charm, memorabilia-lined walls, and relaxed, family-friendly vibe make it a must-visit, whether you’re a movie fan or a pizza enthusiast.
Located in Olde Mistick Village, Mango’s Wood-Fired Pizza Co. is beloved for its New Haven-style, thin-crust pies baked in an 800°F wood-fired oven for that signature char and chew. The menu highlights fresh, local ingredients with choices like the classic Margherita, the Bootlegger (pepperoni, bacon, sausage), and inventive seasonal creations such as the Crankee Yankee (chicken, broccoli). Mango’s also offers gluten-free crusts, salads, and a lively atmosphere—perfect for families or groups enjoying a day in the village.
Nana’s Mystic brings modern craft to the table with naturally leavened sourdough crusts, organic and regionally sourced grains, and inventive toppings that change with the seasons. Their dough is vegan and undergoes a long cold fermentation to develop rich flavor and healthy complexity. Pie options range from classic tomato and pepperoni to creative specials, all baked on the waterfront and paired with artisan breads, pastries, and organic coffee. Nana’s is praised for its quality, fresh flavors, and eco-conscious approach—a true favorite for foodies seeking a unique slice experience.
Rounding out Mystic’s pizza scene are classic favorites like Angie’s Pizza & Pier 27 Lounge, prized for its generous toppings and family-friendly service, and Trattoria Amalfi, where pizza is part of a larger Italian dining experience, featuring authentic pies alongside pasta and seafood.
In Mystic, pizza is more than just a quick bite—it’s woven into the culture, offering everything from nostalgia and wood-fired technique to locally sourced artisan pies. Whether you’re exploring historic downtown, strolling the village, or gathering family for a night out, Mystic’s pizza restaurants serve up delicious variety in vibrant, welcoming settings.
Super Weekend Ahead! The February air in Mystic is crisp and refreshing, with the village glowing in winter charm and the sound of the river providing a soothing backdrop. Whether you’re here for the “Big Game” energy or quiet coastal walks, there’s a unique warmth …
Experience the Magic: Olde Mistick Village Festival of Lights Shines Bright! Mark your calendars, Mystic lovers! The enchanting Festival of Lights at Olde Mistick Village is returning this year, promising an unforgettable evening bathed in the warm glow of thousands of luminaries. Get ready to …
Mango’s Wood Fired Pizza: Mystic’s Artisan Pie Destination Nestled at 27 Coogan Boulevard, in the heart of Olde Mistick Village, Mango’s Wood Fired Pizza stands as a beloved, family-owned staple in Mystic, CT. Since its founding, Mango’s has earned a reputation for excellence, serving up …
Palmer’s Provisions & Pizza: Noank’s Nautical Gem Near Mystic Tucked in the heart of Noank village at 17 Pearl Street, just a short hop from downtown Mystic, Palmer’s Provisions & Pizza has quickly become a must-visit culinary and cultural anchor for locals and visitors alike. …
Nana’s Bakery & Pizza: Mystic’s Organic Haven for Artisanal Breads and Inventive Pizzas Tucked along the waterfront at 32 Williams Avenue in Mystic, CT, Nana’s Bakery & Pizza has carved out a vibrant niche as the town’s destination for sustainably crafted, flavor-driven food. This organic …
Mystic Pizza: The Legendary “Slice of Heaven” in Downtown Mystic Mystic Pizza, located at 56 West Main Street in the heart of downtown Mystic, CT, has earned its iconic status as more than just a pizzeria—it’s a beloved cultural landmark and a must-visit for movie …